HomeMy WebLinkAbout2008-01-16 PACKET 08.D.REQUEST OF CITY COUNCIL ACTION COUNCIL AGENDA
MEETING ITEM #
DATE 1-16-08
e
PREPARED BY: Finance & Admin Services Ron Hedberg
ORIGINRTING DEPARTtvIENT STAFF AUTHOR
������,�����,�������������,�,���,�������������,���
COUNCIL ACTION REQUEST:
Direct staff on the filling of vacancies created by implementing the Early Retirement Incentive
Plan
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
By motion adopt the direction recommended in the report postponing the filling of vacancies
created by implementing the Early Retirement Incentive Plan.
BUDGET IMPLICATION:
BUDGETED AMOUNT
ACTUALAMOUNT
ADVISORY COMMISSION ACTION:
❑ PLANNING
❑ PUBLIC SAFETY
❑ PUBLIC WORKS
❑ PARKS AND RECREATION
❑ HUMAN SERVICES/RIGHTS
❑ ECONOMIC DEV. AUTHORITY
❑
DATE
REVIEWED
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS:
� MEMO/LETTER:
❑ RESOLUTION:
❑ ORDINANCE:
❑ ENGINEERING RECOMMENDATION:
❑ LEGAL RECOMMENDATION:
❑ OTHER:
ADMINISTRATORS COMMENTS:
APPROVED
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
DENIED
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
�„ �cc..�,s°� �—� P /I �a°,
City Administrator Date
��,���������������,����«��������������,�����,�����
COUNCIL ACTION TAKEN: ❑ APPROVED ❑ DENIED �OTHER
�/�.� ��,�;���'
;,
���
• • .•- •
�
� �� ��' � � � � �
� � � •
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
RE:
Introduction
Honorable Mayor and City Council
Ryan Schroeder, City Administrator
Ron Hedberg, Director of Finance & Administrative Services
January 11, 2008
2008 / 2009 Staffing
In May 2007, Council received a staffing and operational expenditures study. The
conclusions of that study were that generally our staffing and operating expenditure
levels were lower than most peer communities. Our ability, however, to fund spending
levels is also lower than most peer communities and therefore our tax rate was higher
than most peer communities. Spending and staffing were in the lowest quartile in the
general government area and in the next quartile for public safety and public works
spending and staffing with spending approaching the mean among peers in the larger
operating areas. While those are positive results, our tax capacity per capita, as a
measure of revenue raising ability, is in the lowest quartile resulting in a tax rate in the
top one third among peers.
During 2006 we began forecasting a slow down in new home construction and market
value growth for 2007 and beyond. These forecasts have proven to be generally
correct with taxable market value growth for 2008 at 4 percent with new home
construction permit values during 2007 (impacting 2009 market values) down 60
percent from the prior six years.
Discussion
As we began planning for the 2008 budget it became clear that adjustments were
necessary during 2008 (or before) in order to respond positiveiy to fiscal challenges we
will experience in at least 2009 and 2010. One approach that was approved by Council
on September 19, 2007 was implementation of an Employee Retirement Incentive Plan.
This incentive has been implemented and has resulted in five retirements taking effect
between the plan adoption and January 15, 2008. Additionally, two additional full time
staff have left employment creating additional vacancies. Enclosed is an accounting of
the vacant positions with separation costs and expected savings in 2008 and 2009. If
these positions remain vacant in both years the General Fund can save approximately
$153,000 in 2008 and $282,000 in 2009. Savings for ali funds would total $188,000 and
$404,000 for 2008 and 2009 respectively.
Vacancies have resulted across the organization. Included are three office support
positions (two within Public Safety and one in Community Development). Also included
are three public service worker positions in Public Works and one supervisory position
at the Ice Arena. It is our belief that it has been Council intent to recoup all costs of
severance from these positions prior to backfilling of any positions. We further believe
that in adopting the retirement program Council anticipated savings during the 2008
budget year with substantial savings during the 2009 budget year. Upon that belief we
are recommending backfilling of one of these vacant positions during 2008 with a full
time regular position. We are further recommending that departments be authorized to
acquire short term itinerant staffing during peak periods but that no additional regular
positions be authorized for replacement at this time.
Ice Arena
On or about October 1, 2008 we are scheduled to open an expansion to the Ice Arena.
One of the vacancies created with the Early Retirement Incentive Plan was the
Assistant Ice Arena Manager. Even though we will be adding an additional sheet of ice
we believe we can operate effectively without replacing at the same position level
however we do need a position to handle this expanded facility. We are recommending
filling the vacant position with a Recreation Program Assistant. It would be expected
that this position have responsibilities in both the Recreation and Ice Arena areas. The
pay range differential for 2008 is $40,898 to $51,122 for the former position and
$33,737 to $42,171 for the replacement position. We would request the opportunity to
fill this position about mid year. Doing so will result in falling short of covering
severance expense during 2008 but will resuit in savings of approximateiy $$24,000
during 2009.
Public Works
We are not recommending replacement of the three public service worker positions at
this time. Peak activities in public works result from snow plowing operations over the
winter months (which as we know are sporadic events) and summer turf and roadway
maintenance in the summer. Two of these positions are in parks with the other in
utilities. All have snow plowing responsibilities although one of the parks positions has
been effectively vacant for well over a year and the department has adjusted to that.
The two retirements are occurring mid January resulting in two months of snow event
potential post retirement. We believe the department has the ability to handle that crew
shortage through scheduling and equipment adjustments. Included in equipment
adjustments may be moving forward the acquisition of larger snow removal equipment
to allow for consolidation of two cul-de-sac plow routes. See the attached memo from
Joe Fischbach and attached snow piow route maps and equipment. For the park
related summer peak events we have made significant itinerant staffing enhancements
over the past several years and therefore we believe staffing capacity exists from a
budget perspective short of backfilling this second park vacancy at this time. Another
area to look for time savings will be how we provide (if at ali) forestry services to the
public with the vacancy occurring the Forestry area. We further believe that the deficit
in staffing created in the utility function has already effectively been closed by
completing the remote meter installation program which reduces staffing requirements.
Below is a recap of the staffing FTE's included in the Public Works divisions over the
past several years. This count does not include the Ice Arena or Recreation positions,
but includes all the other Public Works divisions from Streets to Snow and Ice, Parks
Maintenance, Public Works Administration, Fleet Maintenance and the Utilities. The
numbers for 2008 have been adjusted for vacancies created by Gary Anderson, Bob
Campbell and John Klinkhammer. In addition, during the budget process for 2008, the
part-time receptionist position at Public Works was eliminated and is not included in the
staffing counts below for 2008.
Reg FT & PT FTE's
Seasonal FTE's
1999 2000
32.1 34.5
4.1 3.6
36.2 38.1
2001 2002 2003
34.7 35.8 37.0
4.8 4.9 5.1
39.5 40.7 42.1
2004 2005 2006
37.6 38.6 38.6
5.4 6.3 7.0
43.0 44.8 45.5
200� 2oos
39.6 36.2
7.7 7.7
47.3 43.9
In addition to these staffing additions over the years we have also contracted out work
or acquired equipment that has made the department more efficient.
Some examples include:
• Outsourcing meter reading in January 2003, with no reduction in staffing.
. The remote meter reading installation program is nearing completion during 2008
and has included significant time commitments over the past few years by up to
two employees while they installed over 8,000 remote meter reading devices.
. The purchase of a smaller refuse truck to service park trash barrels in a much
more efficient manner. It has been estimated that this saved '/z FTE of mainly
summer help but has made the operation more efficient.
. The conditions of the streets nave been improved significantly since the start of
the Pavement Management program and the expending of over $33 million once
the 2008 project is compieted. It is felt that some saving of maintenance time
has occurred over the years because the roads are in better condition.
• Over the years the equipment fleet has purchased better and more specialized
equipment resulting in efficiencies gained.
. Additional part-time summer hours have been added in the parks maintenance
area as reflected above.
Public Safetv
We are also not recommending repiacement of the three office support positions at this
time. It should be recalled from the staffing study that public safety office support
stafFing in Cottage Grove is significantly greater than all but a few peer communities.
The Department had already started movement to adjust to this as we move to a
regional records management system. Although in the immediate term the department
has been experiencing backiogs in processing which will need to be addressed with
additional hours in part-time temporary staff until the records system is fully
implemented. This along with further adjustments in staff assignments and training will
allow the department to function adequately absent these positions.
Communitv Development
In Community Development we are recommending taking a wait and see approach.
While the department took on responsibilities for the reception desk during 2007
(following the elimination of the central reception position - one FTE) an additionai
0.5FTE's were added to the Community Development Department by making a part-
time person fulltime. With the vacancy created through the Early Retirement Program,
the department is currently down 0.5FTE's and has assumed the duties of the front
desk. Some of the front desk responsibilities that have moved to the Community
Development position inciude processing utility bill payments which have tripled in
volume with the transition to monthiy billing shortly after closing of the reception desk.
Another responsibility is the processing of dog licenses at year end. Last year we
offered citizens a multi-year license option which helped reduce the strain this year.
One remaining responsibility that we wili need to address will be assistance with
elections, mainly assisting with absentee balloting at election time. The general election
requires a significant time commitment, particulariy with increasing numbers of
absentee voters. This election coverage may result in the need for additional hourly
temporary help.
Furtner, we are projecting construction activity for 2008 at levels not as great as in 2007
which from a single family home construction perspective was down 60% from the prior
six years. Remodeling and commercial construction continued at an active pace during
2007 but we do not have reason to believe that this will continue during 2008 due to a
predicted economic slowdown. It should be anticipated that discretionary spending
such as many remodeling projects, will fall off in this environment. We also believe we
have the capacity from within other general government departments to reallocate
staffing to community development for some back office support during peak activity
periods. If permit activity does in fact pick up beyond projections we would adjust
course at that time. This approach is the same one taken in 1999 when we went from
four building inspectors down to two through attrition during another period of deciining
permit activity. During that period we hired itinerant staffing until activity appeared to be
headed north once again.
Staff Recommendation
With the above approach we believe we will experience some savings during 2008 but
more importantly we will be positioned to experience savings during 2009 which may
cover payroll inflation during that year. Given that payroll is our largest single expense
this approach should allow for the 2009 budget to be presented absent a significant tax
increase upon the citizenry. We believe this is of utmost importance as it would be
difficult for taxpayers to understand the need for growth in government during what may
be a very trying time for many within this community.
We also believe that by keeping these vacancies open with a wait and see approach
and not filling vacant positions with regular positions in the near future will position the
City to be able to react to possible declines without the need to resort to the laying off of
employees.
Council Action:
By motion adopt the direction recommended above.
2008 staffing recommendation
100 0500
100 1000
�oo zzoo
100 1500
250 3700
250 3700
610 3000
610 300�
620
6iY9
3100
9660
2008 Wage Costs and Savings with ERIP and WC Settlement
�
100.00%,Tiz �oca1517
100 00% McBride Local 517
100.00% Klinkhammer local49
100.00%,Anderson Local49
100 00 % Bot, Jr.
100 00 %
75.00% Campbell
100.00 % Podtburg
25.00% Campbell
25.00 % I Kinsey
Secretary Fl
Secretary FT
Farester FT
Public Service Worker FT
� �
a � �
� � � ,
4 R, �,
. � K �
2„^ 2` E
o �b �
' � � ..... �. �.
21.3107 0.0000� 12
18.8799 19.6112� 12
21.3107 0 0000, � 1 50
24.0402 0.0000'1�.50
23.7235 0 0000, 12
Non-Rep Ice Arena Assistant Manaqer FT 27.0177 0.0000 12,
Non-Rep Rec Program Asst FT 16 2197 0.0000 5
Local49 PubiicServiceWorker FT 23.1235 0.0000�11,50
Local517 Reception�st PT 18.0044 0.0000 11
�
Local 49 Pub6c Service Worker FT 23.1235 O.00OOI11.50
I
Local517 Secretary FT 21.3107 0.0000 12
I
�
�
Y
0
N
�
a6
� �
¢.
iC
� e�_ W.
42,300 11,
40,300� 51,800
42,500� 54,500
47,9001 58,600
48,100 61,340
562001 70,400
14,1001 21,800
46,100)
12,900
46,100
44,300
Totais
47,300
�4,800
15,800
14,700
� �
E
a t °�
� �
� ' �
� ;
� �
� � ! �
3,589
0
2,131
1.249
0 0 48,700
35,066 '16,926
28,814 7,337
0 0
9,605I 2,446
3,717 1,196
13Q994 34,573 48,700
� �
�
� �
�
m ��
�' �
� ��,,,,(('' �
J d G U
. W . �� �
� �- � 1- W.YL. .
14,740 27,560
0 51,800
16,678 37,822
35,344 23,256
48,700 12,640
Fund Savings 153,078
51,992 78,408
21,800
Fund Savings 3,392
36,150 11,150
14,800
Fund Savings 25,950
12,050 3,750
Fund Savings 3,750
4,913 9,187
Fund Savings 9,187
220,567 788,573
AIIFunds
2009 Savings Not Replacing Any Positions but Asst Arena Manager with a Rec Program Asst
�
�
� � � ¢
C � q , � � � ' � �
W � � � �
100 0500 75.00% Kinsey Local517 Secretary FT
100 0500 100.00°/a Tix Local 517 Secretary FT
100 1000 100.00%,McBride Locai517 Secretary IFT
100 1500 100.00% Anderson Locai 49 Public Service Worker FT
100 2200 100.00% Klinkhammer �ocal49 Forester FT �,
250 3700
250 3700
610 3000
610 3000
620 3100
660 9660
100 00% Bot, Jr.
100.00%
75A0% Campbell
100.00% Podtburg
25.00% Campbell
25.00% Kinsey
FT
PT
Non-Rep Ice Arena Asst Manager FT 27.8300 0.0000 0.0000
Non-Rep Rec Program Asst FT 16.7100 17.5000 18.1100
Local 49 Public Service Worker
Local517 Receptionist
Locai 49 Public Service Worker
LocaI517 Secretary
FT
O
V
3
�
Yn
r
�
�
O
�
�
�
c
,k
�
� ',
� � —
U
3 �
Q} , m
� �
L ,�
� � �
N
� C
202000 20.9800 0.0000
21.9500 0.0000 0.0000
23.8200 0.0000 0 0000
24.7600 0.0000 0.0000
23.8200 0.0000' 0.0000
18.5400 0.0000 0.0000
12
12
12.00'
12
12.00
12
12
12.00
12
23.8200 0 0000 0 0000 12.00
FT I 21.9500 0 0000 0.0000 12
�
�
�i
�
�
�
W
45,700
43,100
45,700
49, 500
51,500
Fund Savings,
57,900
36,800
Fund Savings
49,500
14,500
Fund Savings
49,500
Fund Savings
45,700
Fund Savings
2009 Savings
�
m
c6
�
b
�
43,500
55,100
58,100
62,940
62,700
282,340
72.300
48,000
24,300
50,200
16,600
66,800
16,800
16,800
14,500
14,500
404,740
,dx����; �'�
� �� � � . -•
�,°;.� •.
To: Honorable Mayor and City Council
From: Joe Fischbach, Management Analyst ��
Date: January 11, 2008
Subject: Snow and Ice Control Operations
Backqround
As part of the future staffing discussions, the operations of snow and ice control must be
discussed. Attached are 2 maps and staff assignments. One map shows the current staff
assignments for road and cul-de-sac snow removal. The other map shows the current trails,
wells and water towers that must be plowed. What are shown on the staff assignment list but
not the maps are the parking lots and adjacent sidewalks that need to be cleared such as City
Hall. The position vacated by Gary Anderson has already been accounted for in the three
attachments. This leaves the positions vacated by Bob Campbell and John Klinkhammer. As
you can see on the attachments Bob Campbell has a cul-de-sac route and John Klinkhammer
has the Hoider Plow route. This means that these routes need to be fiiled or absorbed. StatF
has identified severai options to do this, in no particular order.
. Backfill these positions with personnel that do not have a primary route such as Gary
Orloff and Rick Ait
. Combine routes to absorb these vacancies, this may result in total clearance taking an
hour or two longer
• Reduce priority of trails and parking lots and assign those personnel to fill the routes
vacated by Campbeil and Klinknammer
• Backfili these positions with other staff that are not currently assigned to snow and ice
control duties such as the PW Management Analyst and PW Technician
• Look in to the possibility of contracting aut a portion of the City for snow and ice
removal
The Public Works staff stili has not investigated or researched a long-term strategy for
addressing these vacancies. Staff believes further discussion needs to occur before bringing a
long-term strategy for Council consideration.
Recommendation
Per Council discussion, along with staffing discussion.
Attachments
Public ��orks Snow Removal Operations
Equipment and Persomiel List
Unitff Year/Model
Operator
General Priorities
Tandems \ Streets
31-4101-02 02 Sterling
31-4103-00 00 Sterling
31-�102-93 93 Ford
31-410�-07 07 Mac
31-4104-94 07 Mac
Single A�:les \ Streets
31-400�-97 97 Ford
31-4006-OS OS Frtln
31-4001-94 94 Ford
31-4007-OS 0� Frtlu
31-4005-97 97 Ford
31-4003-04 04 Frtln
31-4002-94 94 Ford
Motor Grader \ Streeis
31-800?-91 91 JD
Cul-d-sacs \ Parking Lots
41-8404-03 0? 1�H Tractor
70-1�05-04 04 Che�ry
31-8201-04 04 JD Loader
31-820�-04 04JD Loader
70-1508-00 00 Dodge
�1-1409-97 97 Pord
41-1403-00 00 Dodge
41-1�10�-07 07 UMC
31-5408-06 06 NH Tractor
41-1408-07 07 GMC
Johnson
Farhman
Podoll
Ja�varski
DaBaere
Niles
Bushey
Rhode
Reiman
Wick
Ohland
Steeber
Olson
Zittel
Burton
Enger
Rleblll$
Campbell
Petersen
Goebel
Henrickson
Gorgus
Flandrich
(arterial and collecior streets, school
zones, comm. areas, hiliy areas with
steeper grades)
(arterial and collector streets, school
zones, comm. areas, hilly areas with
steeper grades)
(as directed)
(city hall, police dept. librar}�, fire
hail ? )
Sidewalks \ Pathwa}�s (school zones�routs. arterials and
70-1 �0'-Ol O1 Ford V-Plow Moen collector streets, comm. areas)
70-1>03-97 97 Ford V-Plow Janssen
31-8=}09-04 04 Holder I�linkl�ainmer
34-8708-9� 9> Bomadier Villanue��a
Roundabout And ;Vlisc. Plowing Assignments (rom�daUout and intersections ��ith
31-1004-07 07 UMC OrloPf reduced visibilit}�, ice areila, pw"s,
�6-li02-07 07 GMC Alt mater facilities)
�1-5005-97 97 Chevy Burtman
CI7Y OF COTTAGE GROVE
2007 TRAIL PLOWING MAP � -
LEGEND
_ wunco����cr+on
�_ �R�'LPiONH/�tAF�S
� C��eLCnLOW
Po0W HC�OERPIOJv
� Ni:'.irlc�l W[LL
� Nil��I��IJJ�IEVl��JUFR
CI �"TIVAiFR(��9
� I`APMPNCO�ENSPALE
�
--� �.—
I
t0-10-2007
,`
I ` _
�_
— 1
P� _—_
n �
/ " —_'
/
�
/
2007 SNOW PLOWING MAP $`� � J �
CITY OF COTTAGE GROVE
- - � �
LEGEND �
Ro��e,a t�:� � ��� � �
Romexa a�mon , :�-?s�, f�,-�?J= �''e
• Route 3a ( I � i — � �
s
f ftnu�e 9a ry� � \�,!. �
�
@ Rn ��e Sa f i.y�Fd ,�
' Rou�e 6a ps�.
P Ro��e]a GoeLel .�
Q RouieBa fpnd.A�. �
� Rou�e 1 hl� ,
�� R vit 2 ,'pFn.mn _
� Roule3 lp Y
YNd% P
� R�wea 3n±, I .
Y /' Roule5 pp��.
� I I
RaNe6 'ry} � —
� __ __ Ra��e � or� _ _ _
_ - eawea mh�� - I �_,._,
� ftoNe9 bx•�. I
�� ��
Rome10 peBana — _ _ __
Rou�e 11 ,
�odlll 4
- l ftu i�e 12 qepyp - � _ �
/ � � Prva�eROatl ,
�r � j Ralmad - 1 —
'I Pa k a tl Open Space - I
:s=�'=�- ---'I,.
� l l
j
.��+,_, s= =. _.
i {
� -.-_. � "' -
=_ "__„""_
� r':'__ _-_�r =„_>:�.�, - .;
"-: -- , v;s�.:;"�.`.:_ =5 - - I
. ,,;a��l"'; ,,," , r5ry _ __: �t.ww...,_.
-::LiGS� `=. � �'�� � `'�y�'3_..,,
_ _ _ _ __ ' = _- _ �"�:%�
� � ' �","""�- � � _ „�v-
.b ��-- [ , "';� „ .>
� � ..'�-�` �_:: T ' -'r.
I F
��,_.=-:.. , �-s�z
.� _,��;��s��# -- — —���
,.,.._�.,...e,_..-._..„,.._...,...,-�. iaio-o�
,. ,...., , �..,.�,..,, �, ,.,,.,..,, �, , �„ , , , , , � ,
( I , ,
�� ��+:
.__�
�-
� , `� � I „ I . ,.. � .. .
��� I I ���� i f j �
� I�' _--�� � � .°'� _��'- � -�-'�-�' � - --
� = � � �_� , L,r�_�`_ �' .l„
y '� �.�w� �7 r t� `�'��� �I �" �--�-C _
iT b N"'��T��� � �—��_
� �� � i-F�lai ���
�� �"�� ��'��� _�= � �
�.�� P N� �4 � � ._. � � -
���� �� - ��.,. ���� -�{ � L L I �
�.w� , . � ' ���a � ��- � p{— 1�, � ?q
.= alu r �`i�„ ( ' �e.¢���I I m ��'_ll I� i I.:..E,
�. � { HiNNNW - �� �",�i /1 !L� � L _
kY" ���� � � i�sr Y - f
�` L � i } ry I I � � L� " I�}
�j 1 E l ��\J' � . -
J _ } _ �__ _ _�I___ ` - - �—_
� � — I
_.� ',a. �_� � _.1 $ I_ _ e ,
��� '�,�_ —� s � '' _T �
i J s
- �'; ivw-_�� I n t r (�,�_ _�� :
� �;-.��'��'�" ,�=T� ' � �
�� —
� �
�..
,�� �
;�� . � �
I � �1 `� :u� �I��� . _'
`� � �� l u � ° ^ws I - �
� 1 / �
I t�61�
� �,�1�� ll [�\
j � Ti I g
I � � 1 � \\�� � b _
� � :.�,,.c . - - - - r -
�I.. 1 i,wTM . -' ' '
I I 5 I /\ \{ / µ' ' _
i �
IL I � � �i�, - '
� �r��_ i I € _
�, — — ,� — ��—i�
- r - �°
i �"
►
1 — � —;--�
I
I u .e I '�. r e
--_.. —�
I�_�� � ( =
CITY OF COTTAGE GROVE �-�_ � � '
.
[ �'- �I_ �1L� ,cn<-. 1' i4�_ � I� , e � , l „ � �� `I , � — � i — _
. I �' _ . — - _ _
. _ _ _ _ _ r�il . I - ?
_ _ _..> - °, - _� ' ' -
2007 SNOW PLOWING MAP �� T '
LEGEND ��� � -.,,,�,��� I `��f}:T_I- � -
,
: r
.
� T�` � i�! � p� 1 , _ ✓ � 7 .(- ,
� Rou�ela ZMd 1-�� ���� {I a �F�, - � /- - I _
�, _
¢ /� �1
Romeza e�n� �. � � _ � ,- � ' i�t � � , i .L NV ,� ,. r __ _ —� ._, f�_j ^" �- -
• Roule3a � �,� '�� �� j - �`�L��II I -
� U � � F� N ����.1
t
__ M Route4a a4Vms � ._ - �' -{�?n �' gl y .� ' �� __ - _ _
�-i', a _ 2 F __ i N �!� i I �Y, ✓ ��
E m Romesa s�e.0 �.h� �� - �\ � - . F# - �1�,°�y,�" � f��W.:��� - ----
4y ��
_ Rou�e 6a POmm " a -.3 � ���. � ': � _ _. , _ _ .. _ _
{ F' � c' � �
p RoNela boe6el � ,s _ J �,L� .e� �e H �,�� � � � _
t �
: �''' ° � i I �
_ � Rou�eOa Ne��m4.r. /� �\� ` :' �� ��1}���] } ��� .�y� y � � I � --
\
a��rei Nil� ` �_l� r � , sr����E; ' i��xn s s".y.� m�:u e_ �' I i
- �� Roite2 fiM1mm� = Z �^h � a I�F 4 _ � -� I I i� . __._..II -
- Rou�c3 Eu.hM � . ' � .\_ ..,w ^ 1✓ � • l t t `
� . ..� ,` • M' �-
- Rn��e4 phode -
'� • 1 €' ��
� ; Ro�,� s � :- , ' _. ` r�'
, E _
. , -- ae�ma� _�� i ' —_- . , �-- _- -
. � � - 1 - n � ; �r. � _ _ -
- Rou�e 6 Fd - � � �� p � _
, _ . Rou�r � cnia�a ! � � � , . � #' � (� L� , � ^
F � Rou�e B FoM1meo ' • �
' � _ ik � ,,, MII! � I � �_ _�� � � _
- • � . - Rnulr 9 .!eri rsh � ,• _� � ' � d _ �' ^�� � t � _' I, � _ � —_ ' _
�'
o q .
F p°� i \ _.� ��• •' ~' � � �� �" —J
_ 6 }^^ �`�.�� Routvt� Oe9are � .� _ _ ' t t� � �It� �C' � e I __ _
�
4 �m/ ` I t /� __ _ _
RoNe it Pmi) i e - I �� L �' \� 1 -� � _
-� � � Rautei2 SuAv _ . - _ � xz F L_ �: �� � ¶ � p w :� �•����� f`( � �-# � — __ _ - C_ _
°4 B � - \� � _ �__ � I tl1fE i ^� � .
` � PmaleHOatl i - 1 - . _
y � LL � /
�i'� ^ �A Ra roatl � , � - - 9 � ' ' \ \ _ { ° Y - ! £�
E
. _ I ` ' 4 �d . I b _ _
a �k
, PaIXantlOpenSpace � - _
�
� , , . ,�TM„ � I �
- _ : -- - � -- `� -
� ___��, __ � I � � 4 �� -� J �
� � , til
. �_ _,_ _
�,
: ° �
,a ao=.
_.
: . _�,_. :: : i �� \ \ I� I � � � _t��,�_ ,
{ `" � ' - " _ \\ -• — - pj - ----- -- -- -
.. _- _�_.'.= - ��, 1`v.+��^^^%^� .....�' _—g� I g �I t l, �� -
. . ::���.� 3-� _�� _ —� -� � _ a �- �— � .� ��
�_�.
s�;:;�=
����`
���
�
: �. . �m..
'.. , ,.,�„�, , , .,�.., ,,,,,
:.::: .�._.._ - t:5�=-�.r:�s._s-> -
= =__'r.s�;'�= � '°`� — ='=-
-.=,_:>=,-�" ->� i ��'�=:.t;;�
--- _�,. ��_-,:,..
� .-s-�
R;�=.?;�:.'= ='i 3 _ r �r� �" i .
�.�''�,,,.� °� � � – -- _ .� _=°_ r
�r _
—� � � �� ,-;�,,--.
=.F::-_, _ s,az. _ �T 1r.
C- :-_ _'''-=>��__'���'-��= � : --_r_�._ ;'.;:� �:.� V
z�. ;,. � s'-_ � :
10.10 0� ' '�� j�,*.�;'- � .-+ �
' f`.J_ i'T_ -' � 'T'
,,��,„ , , , , , „ v
,„��„ :. - . '�y_ �"7- ��,,,��,
�.
__;
�
�
�—
�,
i r� _